U.S. Tax on Canadian Investments (2019) – IRS Investment Guide FAQ

U.S. Tax on Canadian Investments (2019) - IRS Investment Guide FAQ - Krantz Attorneys

U.S. Tax on Canadian Investments (2019) – IRS Investment Guide FAQ – Krantz Attorneys

When it comes to Canada, the U.S. and IRS taxes, the issue can get very complicated — especially when it involves investment income, such as interest, dividends, and capital gains.

There is a bilateral tax treaty with Canada (which impacts the U.S. tax of Registered retirement plans), along with a Totalization Agreement, and FATCA Agreement.

Typical Canadian Investments that may be subject to IRS Tax or Reporting include:

  • RRSP
  • RRIF
  • TFSA
  • PC deferrals
  • Canadian Mutual Funds
  • Canadian Investment Funds

U.S. Tax on Canadian Investments

The U.S. follows a worldwide income model. That means that if you are a U.S. person, the U.S. requires that all if your income (foreign and domestic) be considered at tax-time.

Common misconceptions we come across with Canada and the U.S.:

  • There is a tax treaty, so my income is not taxable in the U.S.
  • Canadian taxes are high, so I do not need to file in the U.S.
  • RRSP and RRIF escape tax liability at the state level as well.
  • Deferred earnings in a PC are automatically safe from GILTI

Canadian Investments

The following is a list (non-comprehensive) of common investments a person may have in Canada.

With Canada, each investment should be analyzed according to general tax law, along with the three main U.S./Canadian Tax agreements, which include:

1. RRSP (Registered Retirement Savings Plan)

This plan is recognized by the U.S. Therefore, until a person takes any distributions, they do not have to report any income on the accrued growth within the fund (States may tax the growth).

An individual taxpayer used to have to make an annual election, but that was eliminated a few years back and applied retroactively.

If a person enters the Streamlined Program (and previous OVDP), the penalty associated with the RRSP was waived.

2. RRIF (Registered Retirement Income Fund)

Like an RRSP, this plan is recognized by the U.S. Therefore, until a person takes any distributions, they do not have to report any income on the accrued growth within the fund (States may tax the growth).

An individual taxpayer used to have to make an annual election, but that was eliminated a few years back and applied retroactively.

If a person enters the Streamlined Program (and previous OVDP), the penalty associated with the RRSP was waived.

3. RESP (Registered Educational Savings Plan)

Similar to an 529A, this plan is used as a Savings Plan in Canada. It receives the same benefits as indicated above, BUT when it comes to the Streamlined Program or prior OVDP, the RESP was not specifically excluded from the penalty base – although the taxpayer can take the position that it too should be waived.

4. Bank and Investment Interest

Bank interest is taxable. This is the general rule, even if you have a common TD Canada investment account or similar bank account, and even if the money is not being withdrawn.

5. Mutual Funds

Canadian Mutual Funds (aka Foreign Mutual Funds) are very complicated. Generally, Foreign Mutual Funds are considered PFIC (Passive Foreign Investment Company). If you do not receive any distributions, the analysis may be more simplified.

But, if you did receive distributions (even if they were re-invested)  there may be some significant tax analysis and reconciliations required to determine if you have any excess distributions.

Foreign mutual funds are disclosed and calculated using IRS Form 8621.

6. Dividends and Capital Gains

Dividends and Capital Gains are generally taxable (aside from non-distributed gains from RRSP and RRIF). Depending on the type of investment, you may be able to receive preferred qualified dividend treatment, or long-term capital gain.

Generally, the $250K/$500K primary home exclusion and depreciation rules (40 years S/L) also apply.

7. Professional Corporations

Many of our clients in Canada have a Professional Corporation – they are very common due to the tax deferred treatment of (usually) a large portion of income. That income is deferred into various investments, and only taxed at distribution, similar to a 401K.

With the introduction of GILTI, the IRS may no longer treat the deferred portion of the income as non-taxable – even though technically they are “retained earnings” deferred into approved Canadian Investments.

8. Foreign Rental Income

This is a common misconception. Let’s say you earned $10,000 in rental income, but had $11,000 in expenses and taxes – no income to report, right?

Yes and No. Yes, you earned gross rent income, but no, you will have no net income. Nevertheless, the income and expenses have to be parsed out, and reported annually on a 1040 Schedule E.

9. Interest Earned on Future Property Development

This is very common in many developing countries. A client will have paid an up-front fee to a developer for a property(s) abroad. During the time the property is being constructed, the investor (you) receive interest on the money you invested.

This ROI interest income must be included with your taxes.

10. Retirement Contributions

This will be impacted. Oftentimes, if there is a treaty (Canada you may receive tax deferred treatment on the growth, but not necessarily on the contributions, vs. a non-tax treaty county (such as Singapore) — where a CPF retirement fund does not receive U.S. tax deferred treatment.

10 Tax Tips (and Misconceptions) to be aware of:

1. Foreign Tax Credit

If you already paid tax on foreign income, you may be able to receive a Foreign Tax Credit in the U.S.

2. Foreign Tax Credit Refund

If the tax money you paid overseas was refunded to you, it may not be worth the headache to claim the credit, since you will have to adjust your tax returns in the future.

3. Income/Gifts

If your parents are managing your accounts, and you let them keep the income (what a nice son/daughter you are), that does not default to income assignment. Rather, it generally means you report the income and you gave them a gift.

4. Employment Provident Funds

EPFs are through employment, and you may be able to defer tax on the growth, per the a U.S. Tax Treaty (if applicable)

5. FATCA

Just because the FATCA Agreement may exempt certain foreign institutions from having to report accounts, does not mean you (as the individual investor) are exempt.

6. FBAR

If you have to file an FBAR you may also have to file a Form 8938 (or vice versa) – in other words, just because you file, does not mean you can avoid filing the other, if you meet the requirements for having to file both.

7. Foreign Earned Income Exclusion

You may be able to exclude certain earned (not investment) income if you meet either the Physical Presence Test or Bona-Fide Residence Test.

8. Transferring Account Ownership

Once you learn about reporting, the knee-jerk reaction is to consider transferring the accounts to another person. This only makes matters worse, because not only will you be out-of-compliance – but it will look bad to the IRS.

9. Calling the IRS Before Getting Into Compliance (Place Holder)

If you are considering getting into compliance, another knee-jerk reaction is to call the IRS to let them know you plan on getting into compliance. The problem is you may not even be on their radar. By calling them, you have now put yourself on their radar.

10. Be Cautions of Inexperienced Counsel

This has become an epidemic. Inexperienced attorneys tout experience they do not have, and puff their prior experience to make it seem like they have experience in this area of law, when they really do not.

Be sure to vet your attorney properly before retaining a firm.

What if You Have Unreported Income or Assets?

If you are out of compliance, the penalties can be severe. Therefore, you may consider entering IRS offshore voluntary disclosure/tax amnesty, before it is too late.

Krantz Attorneys, A PLC

We have successfully represented clients in more than 1,000 streamlined and voluntary disclosure submissions nationwide and in over 70-different countries.

We are the “go-to” firm for other Attorneys, CPAs, Enrolled Agents, Accountants, and Financial Professionals across the globe.

International Tax Lawyers - Krantz Attorneys, A PLC

International Tax Lawyers - Krantz Attorneys, A PLC

Krantz Attorneys: Our international tax lawyers practice exclusively in the area of IRS Offshore & Voluntary Disclosure. We represent clients in 70+ different countries. Managing Partner Ezra Krantz is a Board-Certified Tax Law Specialist Attorney (a designation earned by < 1% of attorneys nationwide.). He leads a full-service offshore disclosure & tax law firm. Ezra and his team have represented thousands of clients nationwide & worldwide in all aspects of IRS offshore & voluntary disclosure and compliance during his 20-year career as an Attorney.

Ezra holds a Master's in Tax Law from one of the top Tax LL.M. programs in the country at the University of Denver. He has also earned the prestigious IRS Enrolled Agent credential. Mr. Krantz's articles have been referenced in such publications as the Washington Post, Forbes, Nolo, and various Law Journals nationwide.
International Tax Lawyers - Krantz Attorneys, A PLC

Latest posts by International Tax Lawyers - Krantz Attorneys, A PLC (see all)